|
|
Not a First Ammendment Right
Dear Editor,
    Every business in Rapid City is regulated by the City. Many of the regulations are for public safety, some are for “quality of life.”
    For public safety, the City can require businesses to have safe buildings, fire sprinklers, safe electrical systems, safe heating systems, paved parking lots, and even elevators. There are many other similar regulations.
    For quality of life, the City requires certain landscaping, regulates sizes of signs, controls noise levels, among other rules.
    Imagine if businesses claimed that dilapidated buildings, muddy parking lots, huge signs, or uncontrolled noise were their “free speech?”
    For public safety and quality of life it is reasonable for the City to regulate Adult Oriented Businesses. Do you want the Rapid City area to be known for its several different AOB’s, or do you want Rapid City to be a safe place to raise a family?
    If you want a safe place to live with a good quality of life, vote FOR the regulations of AOB’s on 8 April.
    Mrs. Lois Ward
SEX-ORIENTED BUSINESSES...
TO REGULATE OR NOT
TO REGULATE
    Twice Rapid City has been declared the rape capitol of America. A group
of concerned citizens began work to change the city's reputation.
    There was NO regulation of Adult (sex) Oriented Businesses (A.O.B's) in
Rapid City. Mayor Jerry Munson appointed a broad based task force to study,
and propose if needed, some regulation for the A.O.B's. Ordinance NO. 3856
was drafted, debated in public hearings, and eventually passed unanimously
by the city council. The A.O.B's then hired a petition circulator who
gathered enough signatures to put Ordinance NO. 3856 before the people for a
vote on April 8, 2003. The A.O.B.'s hope the Ordinance will be voted down.
Does the regulation of these businesses violate their constitutional rights?
    The A.O.B.'s main argument against the ordinance is that it violates
their First Amendment rights. This argument that First Amendment rights are
violated by Ordinance NO. 3856 does not stand up under thorough examination!
The First Amendment says, nothing more and nothing less: Congress shall make
no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free
exercise thereof; or abridging the freedom of speech, or of the press; or
the right of the people peaceably to assemble, and to petition the
Government for a redress of grievances.
    The A.O.B.'s cannot argue the establishment and free exercise clauses.
The A.O.B.'s are indeed an establishment, but they are NOT an establishment
of religion!
    They cannot argue they will lose their freedom of speech. They have
spoken freely in public hearings, and still speak freely!
    They cannot argue they will lose their freedom of the press. TV, radio
and newspaper press has covered both sides of the issue from the beginning.
Even now, leading up to April 8th, they are allowed letters to the public in
the Rapid City Journal.
    They cannot argue that their right...peaceably to assemble is abridged
by the ordinance. The ordinance DOES NOT CLOSE those businesses, NOR
PROHIBIT assembling in them.
    They cannot argue that they have been forbidden the right to petition
the Government. They secured official petition signatures to put the
ordinance on the April 8, 2003, ballot!
Does the regulation of these businesses violate someone's right to choose?
    The right to choose is not an open-ended privilege. One cannot choose
any behavior that harms other citizens.
    Once behind the wheel of an automobile on a public highway, a driver may
not choose to drive in public in any way which causes harm to others. The
driver's driving is regulated!
    Hunters love to hunt, but Rapid City has a law against hunting inside
city limits. No hunter may choose to hunt in this city because he has a
right to hunt. If he chooses to hunt, he is regulated in his choice within
the city limits, and even elsewhere.
    Rapid City has ordinance regulations against citizens parking junk
vehicles on their private property. I know, because our church was asked
several years ago to remove an older bus, that had not been used in over two
years, from the property. The old bus was sold to comply with the
ordinance, which should have done much earlier!
    Many people choose to smoke and drink. Smoking and drinking are free
choices, but choices regulated in public places. One's right to choose does
not eliminate all regulations!
    If smoking and drinking can be regulated in Rapid City's public places
and establishments, sex and sex-oriented activities can be regulated,
regardless of one's right to choose!
    Come April 8th, every registered voter may choose to vote or not to
vote. That right is not abridged, but it is regulated. The voter must be a
registered voter in Rapid City, and must vote only in designated places.
Even our voting rights are regulated!
Does the regulation of these businesses violate their moral rights?
    We have heard, You cannot legislate morality! You cannot impose your
morals on us! History would read very differently if President Abraham
Lincoln had said, I cannot impose my moral values on other people. When
President Lincoln issued the Emancipation Proclamation, he imposed his moral
values on the whole nation! Slave owners may have said to Mr. Lincoln, You
cannot impose your moral values on us! We have the right to engage in the
slave traffic! Not so, according to Mr. Lincoln's moral values.
    Teddy Roosevelt said, To educate a man in mind and not in morals is to
educate a menace to society. He also said, There are those who believe that
a new modernity demands a new morality. What they fail to consider is the
harsh reality that there is no such thing as a new morality. There is only
one morality. All else is immorality. There is only true Christian ethics
over against which stands the whole of paganism. If we are to fulfill our
great destiny as a people, then we must return to the old morality, the sole
morality. And if we are to do that, then the church must prepare us for
such a task. We accept Mr. Roosevelt's face on Mt. Rushmore, but will we
accept his morals in our city? Churches can, and must, prepare the way by
manifesting an example of high morality in the community.
    Article VI, Section I, of the South Dakota Constitution, reads: The
stability of a republican form of government depending on the morality and
intelligence of the people, it shall be the duty of the Legislature to.....
It is very clear from this constitutional statement that our republican form
of government exists, depending on the morality and intelligence of the
people! Morality is mandated by the South Dakota Constitution! Morality is
always foundational! We must be a moral people in order to maintain our
republican form of government. From the White House to the Town Hall of
Rapid City, South Dakota, it is a fact that our Constitutional Republic will
stand or fall, depending on the morality and intelligence of the people.
RAPID CITY CITIZENS MUST CHOOSE!
    Will Rapid City, referred to as the Star of the West, become a city
whose Star shines through a stronger moral character, or will it be a city
whose Star is dimmed by the reputation of łthe rape capitol˛ of America? If
Rapid City citizens want a city where strong moral character thrives, they
will vote for Rapid City Ordinance NO. 3856.
|
|